Learning to Give, Philanthropy education resources that teach giving and civic engagement

generationOn

Find Lesson Plans Browse Resources
Philanthropy--Why?: Penny Drive
Lesson 1:
printEmail this Lesson
Lesson
Handouts
Academic Standards
Philanthropy Framework

Purpose:

 

To stimulate the learners thinking concerning the reasons why they might give of their treasure and to have them consider these reasons in light of the impact of their giving upon the recipients of their giving. This lesson may be used with a penny drive or penny war to raise money for a charity.

Duration:

One Fifty-Minute Class Period

Objectives:

The learner will:

  • define philanthropy.
     
  • identify philanthropic acts.
     
  • interpret motivations for giving from a piece of literature.
     
  • explore motivations of their individual giving and compare them to the motivations of others.
     
  • explore individual motivations for giving from the viewpoint of the recipient.
     
  • reflect on his/her personal motivations for giving to the penny drive.
  • hold a penny drive.

Service Experience:

Although this lesson contains a service project example, decisions about service plans and implementation should be made by students, as age appropriate.

The class may hold a penny drive to raise money for a chosen cause. To hold the competition, each class or team competes against all others. Each team has a jar in a central location labeled with the team name and the charity they are raising money for. The idea is to earn the most money for your class or grade. In a penny war, teams try to collect the most pennies, and silver coins count against their total. This creates a competition where other teams try to sabotage the other teams by adding silver coins or dollar bills to the competitors' jars. The value of the coins count against the total, so a quarter subtracts 25 points from a jar of pennies. You can have two winners: one winner is the team that has the most points and another winner collects the highest monetary value.

Materials:

  • Student copies for half of the class of Attachment One: Philanthropic Acts? I
  • Student copies for half of the class of Attachment Two: Philanthropic Acts? II
  • Student copies  of Attachment Three:The Story
Handout 1
Philanthropic Acts? I
Handout 2
Philanthropic Acts? II
Handout 3
The Story

Instructional Procedure(s):

Anticipatory Set:

Write the word ‘philanthropy’ on the display board and ask the learners to share what they know/might recall about the meaning of this word.  Write their shared ideas on the display board, making certain that they understand that the word ‘philanthropy’ means the giving of time, talent, and treasure and taking action for the common good.  Tell them that today, with the Penny Drive soon beginning, they will examine various acts to determine if they are philanthropic.

  • Divide the class into two equal groups, and if at all possible, separate these two groups far enough apart so that they will be unable to hear the conversation of the other group.

     
  • Distribute Attachment One: Philanthropic Acts? I to each of the learners in one of the groups and Attachment Two: Philanthropic Acts? II  to each of the learners in the other group.

     
  • Have the learners read the instructions, and as a group, reach a consensus about whether or not each act is or is not one that could be considered a philanthropic. Have each group assign a spokesperson to report their decisions to the total class when it is reconvened.

     
  • Reconvene the total class and identify the spokespersons. Tell them that you are going to call out the number of each act to be considered and ask the spokesperson to share only a “yes” or “no” for each act. Record these on the display board (for example):

                         Group I    Group II
                     #1  Yes          Yes
                     #2  Yes           No
                     #3  Yes           No   
                     #4 and so on…

     
  • When each number has been called and a vote registered, begin by discussing those numbered acts where the votes are not the same. Have Group I share why they arrived at the decision they did and then have group II share why they arrived at the decision they did. (This will be the first time, hopefully, that the two groups will realize that though the acts are the same for each group, Group II has some additional information concerning a possible motivation for the act.)

     
  • Complete all 12 acts in this manner, leaving it as open ended as possible. (Teacher Note: Despite what might result in a lively debate, allow the learners only enough time for discussion on each act, to get them thinking about the role motivation plays in acts of philanthropy, without requiring them to make a final determination as to whether or not each act is truly philanthropic or not.)

     
  • Once all 12 acts have been shared and discussed, distribute Attachment Three: The Story and have the learners read the story individually and as a class discuss what they think the story is trying to say.

     
  • When the story has been read and briefly discussed, have the learners go back to their original voting sheets.  Ask them, if taking into consideration the fact that what the grandfather told his grandson in this story is true, would it change any of their original votes /opinions about any of the 12 acts about whether they act were or were not philanthropic.

     
  • Take a few minutes for those who are willing to share their reflections to do so.

     
  • Now, have the class list as many reasons as they can for why students might be willing to contribute to the Penny Drive. Once this list is exhausted, have them reflect on what they think will be the motivation for them to personally become involved in the drive.

     
  • Ending this class period, pose the following question to the learners, “Do you think the recipients of the proceeds collected in our Penny Drive will be concerned about why each of you personally contributed to the drive?”

Assessment:

Learner involvement in the class discussions and the depth of understanding and seriousness evident in the sharing of opinions and personal reflections forms the basis for this assessment.

Learning Link(s): (click to view)

Cross-Curriculum Extensions:

  • The learners could be asked to write a one page reflection on whether or not they agree with the grandfather’s opinion found in The Story (Attachment Three).

  • The learners could conduct a survey of ten adults they know, asking them whether or not they agree with the following statement.” It matters little, the reasons we have for giving, it matters a lot that we give.”

  • If time and interest allows for additional conversation around the motivations for giving, consider an additional class period to distribute the Seven Motivations of Giving (Attachment One of the 9-12 Unit entitled Superheroes as Philanthropists: Lesson Two: Identifying Themes in Spiderman and the Seven Motivations of Giving - found at www.learningtogive.org.)  Have the learners, using the Seven Motivations for Giving handout and their Philanthropic Acts? I (Attachment One from this lesson) handout, identify which motivation may have prompted the giving found in each of the identified 12 philanthropic acts. 

Reflection: (click to view)

Lesson Developed By:

Dennis VanHaitsma
Curriculum Consultant
Learning to Give

Handouts:

Handout 1Print Handout 1

Philanthropic Acts? I

Directions: Read each “act” and decide if this “act” is or is not philanthropic. Circle the appropriate response.

           Example  

1. Mrs. Herrera died leaving $100,000                          YES                 NO
    to the Humane Society in her will because
    that is what her deceased husband wanted
    her to do. 

2. Chester Johnston placed $15.00 in                            YES                 NO
    his church’s collection last Sunday because
    his particular faith requires that he contribute
    a portion of his income to the church.

3. April shared her cookie with her younger                   YES                 NO
    brother in the hopes that he would quit
    bothering her.

4.  Mr. White’s car was not working well                        YES                 NO
     so he donated it to the City Mission.

5. For the school Thanksgiving Day food drive,             YES                 NO
    Ayden brought in two cans of peas because
    he didn’t like that vegetable.

6. The Applegate’s needed an end-of-year tax               YES                NO
    deduction, so they donated old clothes and
    used appliances to a nonprofit organization.

7. Karen felt sorry for her invalid elderly neighbor,          YES               NO
    who had been so kind to her over the years,
    so she raked her leaves.

8.  Jerome missed school yesterday due to a cold.         YES               NO
     His friend Jose called him up and gave him the
     assignment that was due tomorrow in math because
     earlier that year Jose did the same thing for him.

9.   Andrea plays in the Middle School Band because     YES                NO
      she did not want to take the PE class offered at
      the same time.      

10. Foster noticed that someone had dropped a              YES                NO
      candy wrapper on the floor in the hallway. He
      picked it up and put it in the trash, hoping that
      he would be ‘Caught Doing Good’ by his teacher.

11. The class all signed a card for Samantha, who          YES                NO
      was in the hospital with pneumonia, as requested
      to do by their teacher.

12. Mr. Ortiz’s arms were full of textbooks, so Kerry         YES               NO
      held the door for him hoping to impress his
      teacher.

Handout 2Print Handout 2

Philanthropic Acts? II

Directions: Read each “act” and decide if this “act” is or is not philanthropic. Circle the appropriate response.

          Example  

1. Mrs. Herrera died leaving $100,000                       YES                NO
    to the Humane Society. 

2. Chester Johnston placed $15.00 in                        YES                NO
    his church’s collection last Sunday.

3. April shared her cookie with her younger               YES                NO
    Brother.

4.  Mr. White donated his car to the City Mission.       YES               NO

5. For the school Thanksgiving Day food drive,          YES               NO
    Ayden brought in two cans of peas.

6. The Applegates donated old clothes and                YES               NO
     used appliances to a nonprofit organization.

7. Karen raked her invalid elderly neighbor’s              YES               NO
    leaves.

8.  Jerome missed school yesterday due to a cold.     YES               NO
     His friend Jose called him up and gave him the
     assignment that was due tomorrow in math.

9. Andrea plays in the Middle School Band.                 YES               NO

10. Foster noticed that someone had dropped a          YES               NO
     candy wrapper on the floor in the hallway. He
     picked it up and put it in the trash.

11. The class all signed a card for Samantha, who      YES               NO
      was in the hospital with pneumonia.

12. Mr. Ortiz’s arms were full of books, so Kerry          YES               NO
      held the door for him.

Handout 3Print Handout 3

The Story

The story is told of young boy who, while walking with his grandfather through the downtown streets of a major city, observed how people giving of their money to those who begged for it.  The boy asked his grandfather this question:

“Grandpa, who was being the most philanthropic?  The people who gave their money in return for the beggar’s performing his/her act (i.e. playing a musical instrument, dancing, juggling, etc.)?  The people who gave their money, seemingly begrudgingly, as if they felt a need to give but wished they hadn’t been bothered?  Or, the people who gave their money and moved on expecting nothing in return?”

The grandfather thought for a moment and then replied,
“To the beggar, they were all the most philanthropic.”

Philanthropy Framework:

Submit a Comment

Unit Contents:

Overview:Philanthropy--Why?: Penny Drive Summary

Lessons:

1.
Philanthropy--Why?: Penny Drive

All rights reserved. Permission is granted to freely use this information for nonprofit (noncommercial), educational purposes only. Copyright must be acknowledged on all copies.

Generated by Points of Light International
Follow generationOn on Facebook
Message