9th-12th Grade
Subjects:
Language Arts, Library / Technology, Philanthropy and Social Studies
Key Words/Concepts click to view
| ELA: | Brainstorming; Reflection; Social/Cultural Issues; Teamwork; Understanding; Universal Themes; Vocabulary |
| PHIL: | 1 lesson genOn; Discrimination; Justice; Trust |
| SOC: | Civil Rights; Equality; Primary/Secondary Sources; Rights/Responsibilities |
Focus Question(s):
What is a world citizen's responsibility to promote and advocate for justice and kindness?
NOTE: Prior to this lesson, use the Blue Sky Activity in which students envision a better world. If you already have a Blue Sky display, revisit it before beginning this lesson.
Purpose:
The purpose of this lesson is to help the learners see that each individual can make a significant contribution to the common good. Students read about Rosa Parks and an example of a philanthropic act that promotes the welfare of individuals and community through inaction in the form of protesting unjust/unfair situations. Students analyze violent situations and propose nonviolent solutions.
Duration:
One 50 minute class period
Objectives:
The learner will:
- identify and describe the contribution Rosa Parks made during the civil rights movement.
- propose nonviolent solutions to difficult situations from history.
- identify how an act of resistance can be a form of philanthropy.
- brainstorm ways that an "average citizen" can work to promote justice and kindness in the school/community.
Instructional Procedure(s):
Teacher Note: Before students arrive, write the following quote on the display board: "I'm just an average citizen. Many black people before me were arrested for defying bus laws. They prepared the way." --Rosa Parks
Anticipatory Set:
As the learners enter the classroom, have a picture of Rosa Parks on display. Ask the learners to identify the person in the picture and share what they know of her and the impact her life had on American history.
- If the students don't have background information about Rosa Parks and the Montgomery Bus Boycott, display or pass out copies of the following article found in the Alabama Department of Archives and History at http://www.alabamamoments.state.al.us/sec55det.html. Have the learners scan the article and highlight key events in the Montgomery Bus Boycott. Ask students to briefly recall the order of events for the whole class.
- Display on the overhead projector a primary source historical document by Martin Luther King, Jr. from the Alabama Department of Archives and History. http://www.archives.state.al.us/teacher/rights/lesson1/doc7.html This typed list tells blacks how to act in a nonviolent manner as they sit down on the bus after the bus boycott is over and the law says they can sit anywhere on the bus.
- Then divide the class into five groups. Give each group a scenario showing the tension on the buses and trains before the Montgomery bus boycott. (See Attachment One: Five Scenarios.) Ask each group to read their scenario and analyze (using Attachment Two: Questions for Discussion) how the scene could have been diffused nonviolently.
- After ten minutes, have a member from each group read their group’s scenario aloud to the class and then share the information on their worksheet. Each presentation should be no more than two or three minutes in length.
- Have the learners share how what they have read and heard relates to the Rosa Parks quote on the display board.
- Write the word philanthropy on the display board and encourage the learners to share what they know about the meaning of this word. Summarize their contributions by defining philanthropy as "giving time, talent, or treasure for the sake of another or for the common good."
- Lead a class discussion focused on the question, "'Why do you think history considers Rosa Parks' action an act of philanthropy?"
- Brainstorm ideas about how students can promote justice and kindness in a nonviolent way and through inaction. Discuss possible projects for a service event. How can they as "average citizens" help promote the common good?
Assessment:
The assessment focuses lesson focuses on the learner's involvement in whole and small group discussions.
Learning Link(s): (click to view)
Have an idea for a Learning Link?
If your Link is accepted for publication on the Web site you will be credited with your name, school, and city.
These Learning Links provide ten quick-and-easy, five-minute mini-lessons to promote student thought and dialogue about service and civic engagement. You may use as many of them as you wish, and in whatever order best meets your needs and the interest of your students. The purpose of these mini-lessons is to provide a deeper understanding of philanthropy (the giving of time, talent, and treasure for the common good) and to reinforce the lesson focus. These Learning Links also promote the development of character traits, civic engagement, and student leadership. As appropriate to your grade level, it is recommended that students play an active leadership role in presenting these mini-lessons to their classmates.
- Read: Have you heard of Mohandas Gandhi? Starting in 1915, he led a nonviolent revolution in India to bring justice and fairness to poor people, women, and people of different faiths. Instead of using the power of weapons to fight against injustice, he used the power of mass civil disobedience. He organized protests and work stoppages against unfair treatment of farmers and peasants, and he successfully turned away the oppression of a foreign government, England, that dominated India. Gandhi chose to speak about truth and fairness rather than violence and hatred. The power to fight oppression comes from the cooperation of people refusing to serve and support an unjust practice. His work inspired Martin Luther King, Jr. to lead the Civil Rights Movement in America and Cesar Chavez to get fair working conditions for California farm workers.
Discuss: What issues of fairness and justice do we need to be aware of today? What unfair or destructive practice have you seen or read about? Is there something you can refuse to take part in or support? There are many injustices in our world—wasted resources, bullying, hunger, poverty, even slavery—what can you do to stand up for a better world? How can our service project remind people of the importance of standing up for the rights of others?
- Read: Sierra Leone, in West Africa, engaged in violent civil war for eleven years from 1991 to 2002. The war affected children directly and indirectly in many ways. Young people watched killing and mutilation firsthand, as rebels shot their friends and families. Many children were killed, and others were orphaned. Orphaned children without resources needed to make a living in jobs that were unsafe or immoral. Through torture and threats, village boys themselves were forced to join the soldiers and start killing and torturing others. Over 1,200 schools were destroyed in Sierra Leone during the war, leaving children without access to education. Statistics gathered by UNICEF show that in Sierra Leone, nearly a third of children die before they are five (UNICEF, 2006). This high mortality rate for children is caused by poverty, hunger, disease, and other effects of war.
Discuss: Even after the war is over, young people need help recovering from the impact of the war. They need help dealing with the emotional impact of what they have experienced. And they need to get back to school. Of the children who survive, many need to work, cannot afford the costs of going to school, or do not have access to a school building. In addition, high mortality rates lower school enrollment. How does low school attendance affect the future of the country? Is education important to the country? Is it a right for all children? What can we do to bring justice to the children of Sierra Leone?
Facts from The State of the World’s Children, UNICEF, 2006
- Read: Nelson Mandela is widely accepted as the most significant black leader in South Africa and a symbol of resistance against the ruling National Party's apartheid policies. From 1964 to 1982, he was incarcerated for his anti-apartheid beliefs and acts. During his years in prison, he consistently refused to compromise his political position to gain freedom. Nelson Mandela was released on February 11, 1990. He received the 1993 Noble Peace Prize. In 1994, Mandela was elected President of South Africa in the first fully representative"There is no easy walk to freedom anywhere, and many of us will have to pass through the valley of the shadow of death again and again before we reach the mountaintop of our desires."
Discuss: How are the life work of Nelson Mandela and that of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. alike and different? What character traits do you think these two advocates share? What do their lives teach us about the character traits necessary to be agents of change for justice and fairness in our communities and the world? democratic election. Nelson Mandela has spent his life working for freedom and justice for all people. He is quoted as saying,
- Read: Civil Disobedience is the active refusal to obey certain laws, demands, and commands of a government. It is one of the primary methods of nonviolent resistance. Through acts of civil disobedience, people can rebel against unfair laws. Historically, it has been highly effective in bringing about change for the common good in many nonviolent resistance movements: in India’s campaign for independence from the British Empire led by Mahatma Gandhi, in South Africa in the fight against apartheid led by Nelson Mandela, and in the American Civil Rights Movement led by Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Dr. King said, "An individual who breaks a law that conscience tells him is unjust, and who willingly accepts the penalty of imprisonment in order to arouse the conscience of the community over its injustice, is in reality expressing the highest respect for the law."
Discuss: Do you agree with Dr. King’s statement? Do you believe that civil disobedience—deliberately disobeying the law for a just cause—is ever appropriate? If yes, under what circumstances? What issues or causes do you believe so passionately about that you would exercise civil disobedience?
- Read: One component that contributed to the success of the Civic Rights Movement in the United States was the music. Music had a vital role in inspiring and motivating the movement. “We Shall Overcome” was one of the most effective songs. The lyrics include, “We shall overcome some day. We'll walk hand in hand some day. We shall all be free some day. We are not afraid some day. We are not alone some day. The whole wide world around some day. Oh, deep in my heart I do believe, we shall overcome some day.”
(Optional: Show the video of Dr. King’s “We Shall Overcome” speech found at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=130J-FdZDtY&feature=related.)
Discuss: As we plan to celebrate Dr. King’s legacy through our service event, what issues related to justice, fairness, and respect exist in our school that we need to overcome? In our community, nation, and world?
- Read: Recently the world paused to recognize a hero by the name of Jackie Robinson who burst onto the Major League Baseball scene in1947, breaking baseball's color barrier for the very first time and bringing the Negro baseball leagues' electrifying style of play to the major leagues. Mr. Robinson entered the all white world of Major League Baseball while the entire rest of world looked on. In the fish bowl of athletic competition, his every move was watched and scrutinized. While having to continue to tolerate much of the racial bias of that time, Jackie persevered and soon he became baseball's top drawing card and a symbol of hope to millions of Americans. Those who wrote about him were quick to say, he was an extremely talented, multi-sport athlete and a courageous man. On the diamond, he electrified the crowds with his speed, fielding agility, and power. He dominated games on the base paths and irritated opposing pitchers with his uncanny ability to drive in runs. But Mr. Robinson’s story of “having been there and done that” does not end with his collection of trophies and plaques.
While continuing to lend his name and offer his talents to civil rights advocacy, Mr. Robinson also established The Jackie Robinson Foundation which provides comprehensive scholarships and support services to minority students enrolled in colleges and universities.
Discuss: What do you think motivates people like Jackie Robinson, who even though often treated unfairly, “step up to the plate” and continue to do what they can to make the world a better place? When it comes to our service event, how might we encourage our classmates to “get off the bench and into the game” even though there may be some who jeer and hurl derogatory comments “from the bleachers”?
- Read: In her new book entitled, Train Your Mind, Change Your Brain (2007) Sharon Bagley, a science columnist for the Wall Street Journal, reports that continued research affirms the idea that the greater one’s sense of emotional security, the less likely one is to be hostile or bias against people who are different from themselves. The greater one’s sense of emotional security the more likely one is to interact with members of groups other than their own and be empathetic and caring toward them.
Scientists define emotional security as feelings of comfort and interdependence with others, an optimistic nature, a realistic self-confident approach to stressful and challenging situations, an acceptance by others, a feeling of being loved by family, a sense of being safe and secure, a self-esteem that says ”I’m certainly not perfect, but I’m OK for now.” If we feel good about our circumstances, and ourselves we tend to be more accepting and tolerant of others.
Discuss: Assuming that the conclusion of this research is correct, what might it have to say about those who involved themselves in activities such as our service event? How might this information be helpful as we encourage others to join with us during this event? Why is it important that we help others gain a sense of their own emotional security? How might our service event help to promote and enhance our own emotional security as well as that of our peers and total strangers?
- Read: In the original movie, City Slickers, starring Billy Crystal, some hard working city people decide to leave the pressures of their city life and check out life on a horse ranch. They thought it would be fun and easy to become cowboys for a time. It wasn’t long, however, before they discovered that being a cowboy took hard work, perseverance, responsibility, and courage. It was this movie and hearing about the gangs and gang violence in Los Angeles California, that inspired Michael McMeel of Agua Dulce, California to do something to help out. He opened up his 10 acre ranch to give “street kids” a chance to meet the cowboys. Over the past 15 year an estimated 10,000 kids ages 10-18 have been given the opportunity to attend Inner City Slickers camps. “For many kids, this experience has helped them to grow and become responsible young men and women,” Mr. McMeel shyly admits.
Discuss: In what ways might our service event require us to be hard working and responsible? It what ways might it require us to persevere with courage? How might this experience help us to grow and become even more responsible young men and women? Mr. McMeel took on some of the toughest cases, kids who operated alone and preferred it that way and was able to get them to cooperate and be a part of a team. What strategies do you think we could use that will help everyone who participates in our service event to see the value of teamwork?
- Read: Korina Smith graduated from High School in 2001. Prior to her graduation ceremony she had already completed 16 mission trips to Third World countries, including three "Teens for Humanity" missions she organized and took classmates to join her. At California State University, she continued to involve her classmates in this work under a more ‘grown-up’ name: INSPIRE. Her efforts captured the attention of The Stone Soup Institute, a leadership foundation that assists people in building a more peaceful and sustainable world. She was selected as one of the world's top 100 "teen heroes." The story of Smith's passion for teaching American youths how to think and love globally through helping less fortunate people is published in Stone Soup for the Teenage World a book filled with life-changing stories of kindness and courageous acts intended to promote good citizenship and public service.
"Korina is amazing," said a spokesperson at the Stone Soup Institute. "She has demonstrated over and over again how much can be accomplished when everybody pitches in."
Discuss: What might motivate someone like Korina Smith to do what she did at her age? Why is it important that everyone pitch in during our service event? How will our service event be an example of an accomplishment in building a more peaceful and sustainable world?
- Read: The Ripple Effect is a term used often in education, sociology, and economics. It depicts the impact of every single thought or act whether that thought or act is deemed extremely important or seemingly insignificant. For example, if a student is not reprimanded to correct a behavior like talking when he or she is not supposed to be talking it is likely that the negative behavior will spread like a “ripple through water”. This means that the rest of the class is more apt to engage in talking at inappropriate times. If someone is seen tossing trash out of their car window, people who observe this negative behavior are more like to imitate it.
Social Psychology refers to the positive aspects of this imitating behavior as the Modeling Theory. The basis of this theory is that by observing model behavior and imitating it, it will result in desired positive outcomes. For example if someone is observed being thoughtful and kind, odds are that those who are the recipients or even those who have just been observers of this thoughtful and kind behavior will be more likely to pass it along; creating a rippling effect ever expanding to include others.
Discuss: The intent of our service event is to promote positive “ripples” in our school, community and world. In what ways will the Modeling Theory play an important role in the success of our event? Why is it important to the success of our service event that we consider the impact of our behavior on others? In what ways might what we accomplish during our service event result in a flood of thoughtful and kind deeds?
School/Home Connection:
Students interview the older members of their family or extended family about their memories and understanding of the significance of Rosa Parks' refusal to give up her seat on the bus in Montgomery, Alabama. Students write an essay about the bus incident and boycott from the perspective of the person they interview.
Cross-Curriculum Extensions:
Reflection: (click to view)
Reflection plays a very important role in promoting student learning. The following suggested activities are ways to help students reflect on their learning after they have participated in a service event. Choose one or more of the activities most appropriate to the service event and your students.
ACTIVITY ONE:
Tell the students that they have been asked to write a newspaper article that will tell the story of their involvement in this recent service project. Since newspaper articles are usually brief and inform their readers by answering the questions Who? What? When? Where? Why? Their article also should be brief and include answers to these five questions. When completed have the students place a symbol on their article that they will recognize as their own when the articles are returned to them. Collect the articles and randomly redistribute them so students will be able to read other student’s work. Depending on time, continue this process until each student has been able to read at least three other articles. Conclude with a brief sharing of students’ thoughts and ideas.
ACTIVITY TWO:
Review the recent service project and have students share their impressions of what took place. Assign students to groups of two and provide each group with a variety of old newspapers. Ask the groups to scan the newspapers looking specifically for articles that speak to a social/societal problem and how this problem was addressed by an individual or a group of individuals. Have them cut out as many of these types of articles from the newspapers as the designated time permits. Have them then select one article from among those they have identified, which they feel most closely represents the intent of this recent service project. Collect these articles, one from each group, and randomly reassign them to other groups so that no one group has its original article. Each group is to look for the similarities and differences they see between the article they have been given and the intent of this recent service project and share these similarities and differences with rest of the groups.
ACTIVITY THREE:
Provide each student with a variety of magazines and/or newspapers and instruct the class that they are to locate at least three company logos or slogans. Give each student a copy of the worksheet (below) and instruct them to cut out and attach the three logos or slogans that they have identified to their worksheet. After a discussion as to why companies might develop and use logos and/or slogans, have the students complete the worksheet. Then have each student briefly share the logo or slogan he/she has selected and why? Distribute a piece of white construction paper to each student. Tell the class that now the challenge is for each of them to come up with their own logo or slogan to be used in promoting this same service project next year and draw/write it on the white construction paper. Once completed, collect and display all of the logos or slogans, without student names. (NOTE: If the actual intent is to come up with a logo or slogan for use to promote this service project next year, voting for a classroom favorite might be appropriate.)
Name__________________
My three logos and/or slogans:
The logo or slogan I selected as having the most public appeal (from among the three logos I have identified) is circled above.
I think this logo or slogan would have more public appeal because….
ACTIVITY FOUR:
Have students consider this scenario. During this service event, if you had been given a digital camera with which to take three pictures for a motivational presentation, which three pictures would you have taken, and why?
Photo #1 (Describe the photo)
Why would you choose this photo to include in a motivational presentation?
Photo #2 (Describe the photo)
Why would you choose this photo to include in a motivational presentation?
Photo #3 (Describe the photo)
Why would you choose this photo to include in a motivational presentation?
Now have each student select their one photo from among the three taken “that will be added to the class album.” Have them share that photo with the class along with the reason for why they selected it as their favorite. After everyone has an opportunity to share, engage the students in a discussion about similarities and difference in the photos selected as favorites and the reasons for selecting it.
Bibliographical References:
Lesson Developed By:
Lydia Alvarez
University High
Newark, NJ 77108
Dennis VanHaitsma
Curriculum Consultant
Learning to Give
Handouts:
Five Scenarios
Scenario #1: A black soldier stepped onto the bus, leaned back, and tossed his cigarette butt out the door. When the bus driver closed the door on the soldier’s extended hand, the soldier thought it was deliberate. He accused the bus driver of racism, and soon the two men were fighting. The fight escalated to a point where the bus driver hit the soldier on the head with a gun. The soldier then reached into his pocket. Fearing the man had a gun, the bus driver threatened to kill him. The soldier left the bus.
Scenario #2: A sixteen-year-old black girl waited for the city bus to take her home around 8:00 pm. As she stepped inside the bus, the driver informed her that there was no more room for “colored” passengers. The young girl threw her money at the driver, cursed, and spit on him. She attempted to push her way past him, but he knocked her out of the bus, threw her to the ground, and held her there until the police arrived.
Scenario #3: A white woman and a black woman boarded a bus on a rainy day. The black woman allegedly pushed the white woman out of the way in her hurry to get out of the rain. The two drenched women fought each other with their umbrellas as they moved down the aisle of the bus. A man who had watched this fight approached the now-seated black woman and hit her with his umbrella. She grabbed his umbrella, and it broke in her hand. She hit the man with the handle from his own umbrella. The bus driver separated them, and there was no more trouble.
Scenario #4: As was her usual custom, a white woman boarded the bus and started complaining loudly about blacks. As the bus approached a stop, she vowed that this morning she was not going to let them move the color boards up (giving blacks more room). She moved to the back of the white section to make her point. After a while the angry woman asked the bus driver to make the blacks stop laughing at her. When he said he couldn’t do anything about it, she cursed and complained loudly. When a black young woman commented, the woman started hitting her. The bus driver separated them. The bus driver claimed that this woman causes trouble every morning.
Scenario #5: When a conductor asked a black man to stop cursing on the train, a fight started. The two men shoved each other angrily. The black man pushed the driver into his seat and pulled out a knife. A motorman came to help. He hit the man over the head with a gun and knocked him down. Another black passenger offered to take the first black man off the train. They got off, and the train made a loop. When the train came back, the black man got back on the train, threatening the conductor with his knife. They fought, and the conductor shot the man.
Scenarios adapted from
Kelley, Robin D. G. Race Rebels: Culture, Politics, and the Black Working Class. New York: Free Press, Distributed by Simon & Schuster, 1996. ISBN 0-684-82639-9
Questions for Discussion
Name: ________________________________ Hour: ____________
Directions: Within your group, read the provided scenario and answer the following:
1. Identify the conflict (fight, argument, shooting, etc.), where it occurred and who was involved.
2. Who instigated the conflict and why did it occur?
3. With the members in your group, discuss any other alternatives that could have resolved the conflict.
4. In the end did those involved gain anything from the incident? Why or why not?